How to buy secondhand clothes for yourself and love them
Buying used clothes cuts the carbon from your wardrobe, but only if you wear them. Here is how to shop secondhand and come home with pieces you reach for.
You buy your kids’ clothes used without a second thought. Then you need a new pair of jeans for yourself and head straight to the mall. Secondhand feels fine for a four-year-old who will outgrow it in six months. For you, it feels like a gamble.
Most of the carbon in a piece of clothing comes from making it. A used pair of jeans has already paid that cost. Buying it new adds the whole cost again. That makes secondhand the biggest cut you can make in your own wardrobe, bigger than any choice about fabric or brand.
This article covers how to shop secondhand for yourself with a plan, how to check fit and quality fast, and how to make sure what you bring home ends up on your body and not in the donation bag.
Go with a list
Walking into a thrift store with no plan is how you leave with three things you never wear. Walk in with a short list instead. “Dark jeans in my size, a navy cardigan, a white button-up shirt.” Three to five items at most.
The list comes from the gaps in what you own. If you have built a small wardrobe that works together, the gaps are obvious. The guide to a capsule wardrobe for busy moms covers how to find them. If you have not, pick the three items you wish you had every morning.
Carry the list on your phone. Shop the list first, and allow yourself one surprise find per trip.
Know your measurements
Secondhand sizes mean little. A size 10 from one decade and one brand fits like a 6 or a 14 from another. The tag is a rough guide at best, and many used items have no tag.
Measure yourself once at home: bust, waist, hips, inseam, and the width across the back of a shirt that fits you well. Keep the numbers in your phone. Carry a small tape measure in your bag. Measuring a waistband takes ten seconds and saves a trip to the fitting room.
For online secondhand shopping, measurements are the whole game. Ask the seller for them if the listing does not show them. Compare to a piece you own that fits.
Check quality in under a minute
A quick inspection catches most problems. Run through this for each piece:
- Hold it up to the light and look for thin spots, holes, and stains, especially under the arms and at the collar.
- Pull the seams gently and look for loose threads or gaps.
- Check the zipper, every button, and any snaps.
- Look at the hem and cuffs for fraying.
- Feel the fabric. Pilling, stiffness, or a shiny spot means it is worn.
- Smell it. Most odors wash out. A strong mildew or smoke smell may not.
A small flaw is not a reason to walk away if you can fix it. A missing button, a loose hem, or a tiny hole is a five-minute repair. The basic mending stitches cover most of it. A broken zipper or a stain across the front is a reason to put it back.
Favor the fibers that last
Look at the fabric tag. Cotton, linen, wool, and silk hold up well and age well. Dense knits and heavy denim last through years of washing. Thin synthetic blends pill and stretch out, and they often look tired by the time they reach a thrift store.
That said, a well-made synthetic piece in good shape is still a better buy than a new one. The carbon has been spent. If it fits and you will wear it, take it.
Shop where the odds are good
Different places suit different needs. A big thrift store has the most choice and the lowest prices, but it takes time. A consignment shop has fewer items, sorted by size, and the quality is higher. Online resale sites let you search by size and brand from your couch after the kids are in bed.
Match the place to what you need. For work clothes, a consignment shop or an online search for a brand you know fits well saves time. The guide to shopping a thrift store for workwear goes deeper on that. For everyday basics, a big thrift store on a weekday morning is hard to beat.
For online orders, buy from sellers who list measurements and show clear photos. Returns on secondhand are often not possible, and even when they are, a return has its own carbon. Buying right the first time matters more than it does with new clothes, and the same is true for all online shopping.
Work clothes are the best category in most thrift stores. Shopping a thrift store for workwear covers the racks to check first.
Try it on, and be honest
Fitting rooms are where secondhand clothes earn their place or go back on the rack. Try on everything. Sit down in the pants. Raise your arms in the top. Bend over. If anything pulls, pinches, or gaps, put it back.
Ask yourself one question: would I wear this on Tuesday? Not to an event someday. On a normal Tuesday with the kids. If the answer is no, it does not come home.
Wash and tailor before the first wear
Wash everything when you get home, following the care label. Most secondhand clothes have been washed, but a fresh wash makes it yours.
Then look at fit one more time. Many pieces go from good to great with a small change. Hemming pants, taking in a waist, or shortening sleeves costs little at a tailor and takes minutes if you sew. A tailored secondhand piece often fits better than anything new off the rack.
Make it a habit, not a hunt
Secondhand shopping gets easier the more you do it. You learn which stores have your size, which online sellers you trust, and which brands fit you. Build a thirty-minute stop into an errand you already run.
The same habits work for your kids’ clothes, and the guide to buying secondhand kids’ clothes pairs well with this one. A family that shops used first, for everyone, cuts the carbon from clothes more than any other single change.
The first step
Measure yourself tonight and save the numbers in your phone. Write a list of three items. The next time you pass a thrift store, go in for twenty minutes and shop only that list.
Keep reading
Related guides
- Style
How to build a low-carbon capsule wardrobe for busy moms
A small wardrobe of clothes that all work together saves time in the morning and cuts the carbon from buying. Here is how to build one in a few weekends.
- Style
How to mend clothes with basic stitches
A torn knee or a missing button does not have to end a shirt. Learn four basic hand stitches that fix most kid and adult clothes in a few minutes.
- Style
How to shop a thrift store for workwear
Work clothes cost a lot and carry a big carbon footprint. Here is how to find blazers, trousers, and blouses at a thrift store in one short trip.