Carbon Moms

Articles › Holidays

How to choose a lower-carbon Christmas tree

Real or artificial, a Christmas tree carries carbon in how it is grown, shipped, used, and thrown out. Here is how to choose one and dispose of it well.

By Mary Jane HowiePublished 2026-11-155 min read


The tree question comes up every year. Real or fake? Big or small? Buy one at the lot or cut one at a farm? Your kids have opinions, and so does whoever has to vacuum the needles.

A Christmas tree is a small part of the season’s carbon. Gifts and travel matter far more, and the rest of the season has its own article. Still, the tree is the choice people ask about most, so it is worth getting right. The carbon in a real tree comes from growing it, hauling it to you, and what happens to it in January. The carbon in an artificial tree comes from making the plastic and metal, shipping it across an ocean, and how many years it stays in use.

This article covers both kinds, plus the living tree option, and what to do with a real tree once the season ends.

If you already own an artificial tree, keep it

An artificial tree already made and already in your basement has paid its carbon cost. Throwing it out to buy a real tree does not undo that. The best thing you can do with it is use it for as many years as it holds together.

  • Store it in a hard box or a bag, not loose in a damp space, so the branches do not break.
  • Fluff and shape the branches each year so it looks full. Most sparse trees are badly fluffed, not worn out.
  • Replace a bad light strand on a pre-lit tree instead of the whole tree. Many strands plug in and can be swapped.
  • If a section fails, use the good sections as a shorter tree, a porch tree, or greenery for the mantle.

When it finally wears out, offer it for free before you throw it away. Someone with no tree will take a tired one. The usual rules for passing on what you no longer use apply.

If you buy an artificial tree, plan to keep it a long time

A new artificial tree only comes out ahead of a real tree if it stays in use for many years. Buy it with that in mind.

  • Buy secondhand first. Thrift stores and local listings fill up with artificial trees in late November and early January. Many are near new.
  • Choose a plain tree over a pre-lit one. Lights fail long before branches do, and a pre-lit tree with dead lights often gets tossed.
  • Pick a size that fits the room you have now and the room you expect to have.
  • Avoid flocked or colored trees if you think tastes will change. A plain green tree stays in use.

If you buy a real tree, buy close to home

A real tree grows for years on a farm, taking in carbon as it grows. Cutting it releases some of that back, and the drive to get it and the pile it ends up in matter too.

  • Buy from a farm or a lot that sells trees grown in your region. Ask where they came from. A tree trucked across the continent carries more than one from a farm an hour away.
  • Cut your own if a farm is nearby and the trip doubles as a family outing. Do not drive two hours for the experience alone.
  • Buy a smaller tree. A tabletop tree uses less of everything and is easier to carry, water, and dispose of.
  • Skip the plastic netting and the stand you will not reuse. Bring a blanket for the car roof.

Keep a real tree watered so it holds its needles and does not become a fire risk. Follow the fire safety rules for your area, keep it away from heaters, and turn off the lights when you leave the house or go to bed.

Consider a living tree

A potted tree with roots can come inside for a week or two, then go back outside. Some families plant it in the yard after the holidays. Others keep it in a pot on the porch and bring it in year after year until it gets too big.

This works best with a species that suits your climate. Ask a local nursery which trees handle a short stay indoors. Keep the visit indoors short, keep the pot watered, and move the tree to a cool porch or garage for a few days before and after so the change in temperature is gradual.

If you plant it, pick the spot with care. A tree planted too close to the house or a fence becomes a problem in ten years. The steps are the same as planting any tree with kids.

Rent a tree if your area offers it

Some cities have tree rental programs. A potted tree is delivered in December and collected in January, then grown another year. Search for one in your area. If it exists, it is one of the lowest-carbon options, and kids like to see the same tree come back bigger the next year.

Dispose of a real tree the right way

What happens to a real tree in January matters as much as where it came from. A tree in a landfill breaks down without air and gives off methane. A tree that is chipped, composted, or burned in a proper facility gives off carbon dioxide instead, which is the lesser problem.

  • Use your city’s tree collection if it has one. Most chip or compost the trees.
  • Take it to a drop-off site if there is no pickup.
  • Chip it yourself or ask a neighbor with a chipper. The chips make good mulch for garden beds.
  • Cut the branches off and lay them over garden beds for winter cover. Cut the trunk for a fire pit if that is allowed where you live.

Remove every ornament, hook, and strand of tinsel first. Metal and plastic do not belong in the chipper or the compost.

Decorate it to last

Whatever tree you choose, the decorations follow one rule. Use what you have and add slowly. Paper chains, salt dough shapes, pinecones, and dried orange slices cost almost nothing and kids can make them. Swap old light strings for LED as they fail and run them on a timer. There is more on cutting the energy from holiday lights in another article.

The first step

If you own a tree, keep it. If you do not, buy a small real tree from a nearby farm this year and compost it in January. Then, if you want something that lasts, watch for a secondhand artificial tree in the week after New Year, when they are everywhere.

Mary Jane Howie

Civil engineer, mom of four, and the writer behind Carbon Moms. She writes about the changes at home that lower a family's carbon without adding work to the week. More about her.