How to choose low-carbon shoes for the whole family
Kids outgrow shoes and adults wear through them. Here is how to buy fewer pairs, pick ones that can be fixed, and pass them on when you are done.
Kids outgrow shoes faster than they wear them out. Adults wear them out faster than they would like. Between school shoes, rain boots, sneakers, and sandals, the shoe pile by the door turns over all year.
Most of the carbon in a pair of shoes comes from making it. A modern sneaker has many parts, often plastic foam and synthetic fabric, glued together in a factory far away. A shoe that cannot be repaired is thrown out when one part fails. Fewer pairs that last longer, and get passed on, is the whole plan.
This article covers how many pairs each person needs, what to look for in a new pair, how to buy secondhand for kids, and how to keep shoes going.
Buy fewer pairs
Most people wear two or three pairs most of the time. The rest sit in the closet. Before you buy, count what each person owns and what they wear.
A short list per person covers most of the year:
- One pair of everyday sneakers or walking shoes.
- One pair of weather boots (rain or snow, depending on where you live).
- One pair of sandals or water shoes for summer.
- One dressier pair if your work or events call for it.
Kids need fewer pairs than adults, not more, because they outgrow each pair in months. Hold off on the extra pair “for later.” Later, the feet will be a different size. One good everyday pair for each person also makes it easier to walk more as a family.
Pick shoes that can be fixed
A shoe that a cobbler can resole lasts years instead of months. Look for:
- A sole that is stitched to the upper, not only glued. You can see the stitches along the edge.
- A leather or thick fabric upper that can be cleaned and conditioned.
- Laces, not elastic or hook-and-loop, on adult shoes. Laces can be replaced.
- A plain design. Fewer glued parts means fewer parts to fail.
Ask a local shoe repair shop what they can fix before you buy. Many can replace heels, resole boots, and re-stitch a seam. The same thinking applies to other products you can repair.
Choose materials that last
Materials matter less than how long you wear the shoe, but they still count. Leather lasts a long time and can be repaired, and secondhand leather is the lowest-carbon version. Canvas is lighter and can be washed. Natural rubber soles grip well and wear slowly. Foam soles are light but wear down fast and are hard to repair.
Avoid thin synthetic shoes that fall apart in one season. They cost less at the register and more over a year because you buy them again.
Buy secondhand for kids
Kids’ shoes are often outgrown with life left in them. Thrift stores, consignment shops, kids’ swaps, and neighborhood groups have bins of them. For a pair that will be worn for a few months, secondhand is the easiest cut you can make.
Check a used pair before you take it home:
- Look at the sole. Even wear is fine. A sole worn through at the heel or the ball is not.
- Press the heel. It stays firm. A heel that folds flat is done.
- Check inside. The insole is flat, not molded deep to someone else’s foot.
- Check straps, laces, and hook-and-loop closures. These wear first on kids’ shoes.
Rain boots, snow boots, and dress shoes are the best secondhand finds because kids wear them least. Everyday sneakers wear more, so look harder. The same checks you use for secondhand kids’ clothes apply here.
Fit matters for growing feet. Have the child stand in the shoe and press to find the toe. A thumb’s width of room is the common guide. If a used pair does not fit right, leave it.
Care for shoes so they last
Most shoes wear out from poor care, not from walking.
- Loosen laces to take shoes off. Crushing the heel breaks the back of the shoe.
- Let wet shoes dry at room temperature, stuffed with newspaper. Heat from a radiator or dryer cracks leather and weakens glue.
- Rotate two pairs if you can. A day of rest lets the inside dry out.
- Clean mud off before it dries. A damp cloth or a soft brush is enough.
- Condition leather a couple of times a year.
- Replace insoles and laces when they wear. Both are small, easy fixes.
- Take boots to the repair shop before the sole wears through to the upper. Early repair is easier.
Line up the shoes by the door with a tray for wet ones. Shoes that live in a pile get stepped on and lose their shape.
Pass shoes on
When a child outgrows a pair, do not toss it in the trash. Pass it to a younger sibling, a cousin, or a friend. Give it to a school or a shelter that takes children’s shoes. Put it in a neighborhood group. Some athletic stores and some charities collect worn-out shoes for recycling. Ask around before you throw a pair out. The article on selling and donating what you no longer use has more.
Keep the next-size-up pairs in a labeled bin so hand-me-downs between siblings are ready when the feet grow.
Start with one change
Before the next pair, check the thrift store first. If it is for a child, that is the whole change. If it is for you, buy the pair you can get resoled. One pair bought this way, and worn for years, cuts more carbon than any special material.
Keep reading
Related guides
- Shopping
How to choose products that can be repaired
A thing that can be fixed gets used for years. Here is what to look for before you buy so toys, gear, and appliances survive family life.
- Kids
How to handle hand-me-downs between siblings
Hand-me-downs cut the carbon from kids' clothes, but only if you can find the right size when you need it. Here is a simple system for a busy home.
- Shopping
How to sell or donate what your family no longer uses
Outgrown clothes, toys, and gear pile up in every family home. Here is how to pass them on so they get used again instead of going to the landfill.