How to plan a lower-carbon Thanksgiving dinner
The turkey, the dairy-heavy sides, and the food thrown away carry most of a Thanksgiving dinner's carbon. Here is how to cut all three and still feast.
Thanksgiving dinner is the biggest meal most families cook all year. A large bird, six side dishes, three pies, and a kitchen that runs from dawn to dessert. Then a fridge full of leftovers that nobody finishes.
Most of the carbon in the meal is in the food, not the cooking. The turkey is the largest single piece. Butter, cream, and cheese in the sides come next. Food that is cooked and then thrown out counts in full and gives nothing back. The oven and the stovetop matter, but less. The drive to get there can matter a lot if the family is spread out.
This article covers the bird, the sides, the leftovers, the oven, the shopping, and the travel. You do not need to change all of it. Pick the pieces that fit your table.
Right-size the bird
A turkey is a lower-carbon meat than beef or lamb, so a turkey dinner is already a better choice than a roast beef. The problem is usually size. Many families buy a bird far larger than the table needs, eat turkey sandwiches for a week, then throw the last of it out.
- Count the guests and buy for the meal plus one day of leftovers, not a week.
- For a small group, roast a turkey breast or a chicken instead of a whole turkey.
- Buy from a local farm if you can. Ask at the farmers market in October. A bird raised nearby skips the long cold truck ride.
- Use the whole bird. Simmer the carcass for stock the next day and freeze it.
If some guests are vegetarian, make one hearty main that everyone will try, like a stuffed squash, a mushroom pie, or a bean and vegetable gratin. Many guests will take a smaller slice of turkey when there is another main on the table.
Make the sides the stars
Sides are where you can cut the most without anyone noticing. Thanksgiving sides are built around butter, cream, and cheese. Vegetables, grains, and beans carry far less carbon and can taste better.
- Roast vegetables with olive oil, salt, and herbs instead of baking them in cream.
- Make a big salad or a slaw. It adds color and needs no oven.
- Cook a grain dish: a wild rice pilaf, a farro salad, or a stuffing made with vegetables and nuts.
- Use broth and olive oil in mashed potatoes and add butter at the table for those who want it.
- Make one cheesy dish, not three.
- Let the dinner rolls, cranberry sauce, and gravy stay as they are. Pick your changes.
What is in season in late November is also what is cheapest and freshest: squash, potatoes, cabbage, carrots, beets, apples, pears, and cranberries. Building the sides around what is in season in winter keeps the carbon down and the flavor up.
Plan the leftovers before you cook
Food waste is the quiet carbon cost of the holiday. Fix it before the first pot goes on the stove.
- Make less. Two sides per four guests is plenty. A pie per six guests is plenty.
- Set out containers before dinner. Ask guests to bring their own. Send everyone home with a plate.
- Put leftovers in the fridge within two hours of serving. Follow food safety rules on how long cooked food keeps.
- Plan the leftover meals. Turkey soup, turkey pot pie, turkey tacos, stuffing waffles, mashed potato cakes. Write them on the fridge.
- Freeze what you will not eat in three days. Soup, turkey, gravy, and cranberry sauce all freeze well.
Your freezer is the best tool you have for keeping cooked food from going to waste. Label everything with the date. The same habits that cut everyday food waste work on the holiday too.
Cook with a full oven
The oven runs for hours on Thanksgiving. Make every hour count.
- Fill the oven. Roast vegetables and bake the stuffing alongside the bird instead of in separate rounds.
- Do not preheat an hour early. Most ovens are ready in fifteen minutes.
- Keep the door closed. Use the oven light to check.
- Cook the sides on the stovetop with lids on, or in a slow cooker on the counter. A slow cooker keeps mashed potatoes or stuffing hot for hours and frees the oven.
- Bake pies the day before while you cook something else.
- Turn the oven off a little early and let the bird rest. It keeps cooking in its own heat.
More on cooking with lids, pressure cookers, and slow cookers is in its own article, and most of it applies to a holiday kitchen.
Shop once and shop close
A grocery trip on the Wednesday before Thanksgiving is crowded, and you will forget something. Plan the menu a week ahead, write one list, and shop once. Each extra car trip for a forgotten can of pumpkin adds up.
Buy what you can from the farmers market or a nearby farm stand. Bring your own bags and containers. Skip the pre-cut vegetables in plastic trays. Kids can peel carrots and snap beans the night before.
Plan the travel with the family
If Thanksgiving means driving to a relative’s house, fill the car. Four people in one car is far better than two cars with two each. Pick up a cousin or a grandparent on the way. If the relatives live far apart, hosting on alternating years spreads the travel out, and so does a longer-term plan for visits.
If the trip is long, make it worth it. Stay the weekend instead of driving back the same night. Combine the visit with anything else you need to do in that direction.
Start with one change
The leftover plan is the easiest place to start. Put out containers, write the leftover meals on the fridge, and freeze on Saturday. Next year, right-size the bird. The year after, turn two of the creamy sides into roasted ones. Nobody at the table will feel the difference, and the carbon falls each year.
Keep reading
Related guides
- Food
How to cook with less energy using lids, pressure cookers, and slow cookers
Cooking dinner uses more energy than it needs to. These habits and tools cut the power your stove and oven use, and most of them make cooking easier.
- Food
How to eat seasonal produce in winter
Winter produce can still be local and lower carbon. Here is what keeps for months, what grows in the cold, and how to get your kids to eat it.
- Food
How to use your freezer to cut food waste and carbon
Your freezer can save the food your family does not finish. Here is how to freeze leftovers, keep track of them, and run the freezer on less energy.