How to pick jewelry and accessories with a lighter footprint
Jewelry, bags, scarves, and sunglasses are small, but mining and fast fashion give them a large carbon cost. Here is how to pick a few pieces that last.
A new pair of earrings for a night out. A tote bag from the checkout line. A pile of plastic bracelets from the party favor bag. Accessories are small and easy to say yes to, so they pile up in drawers.
Most of the carbon in jewelry comes from mining and refining the metal and stones. Gold mining moves a great deal of earth and uses a lot of energy for a small amount of metal. Fast jewelry made from plated base metal and plastic has a different problem: it tarnishes or breaks in months and gets thrown away. Bags, belts, and scarves follow the same pattern as clothes, where most of the carbon is in the making.
This article covers how to wear what you have, buy secondhand, pick new pieces that last, and say no to the things that will not.
Wear what you own
Most people wear the same few pieces most days and forget the rest. Start by emptying the drawer onto the bed.
- Put back the pieces you wear.
- Fix the ones with a broken clasp or a missing earring back. A jeweler or a bead shop can do this.
- Clean tarnished silver with a soft cloth and a silver polish, or a paste of baking soda and water.
- Set aside what you have not worn in a year to sell, give, or pass to a daughter or a friend.
A small collection you can see is one you will use. The same rule works for a capsule wardrobe, and the two go together.
Buy secondhand and vintage first
A piece of jewelry made fifty years ago carries no new mining. Thrift stores, antique shops, estate sales, consignment shops, and online resale sites are full of real gold, silver, and well-made costume pieces for less than new.
What to look for:
- A stamp inside a ring or on a clasp (such as 925 for sterling silver, or a karat mark for gold). A stamp is a good sign, though not a guarantee.
- Clasps that close firmly and chains with no kinks.
- Stones that sit tight in their settings. Tap the piece gently near your ear and listen for a rattle.
- Costume pieces with no flaking plating or green marks where the metal meets skin.
The same shops are the best place for leather bags and belts, wool scarves, and metal-frame sunglasses. A leather bag that is a decade old and still sound will last another decade. Look over seams, zippers, and straps the way you would for secondhand clothes. For the bag you carry every day, see choosing a diaper bag or purse that lasts.
Buy new pieces that can be repaired
When you buy new, buy for repair. Solid metal (sterling silver, solid gold) can be resized, polished, soldered, and re-set for a lifetime. Plated base metal cannot. A good jeweler can fix a solid chain for less than a new one costs. Once the plating wears off a thin chain, it is done.
For bags and belts, look for:
- Full-grain or top-grain leather, or a thick canvas, with stitched (not glued) seams.
- Metal hardware, not plastic.
- A zipper that runs smoothly and feels heavy.
- A maker who sells replacement straps or offers repair.
For sunglasses, pick a frame with metal hinges and screws. A shop can replace lenses in a good frame.
Ask where new metal and stones come from
If you buy new gold or diamonds, you have a few lower-carbon choices. Recycled gold and silver are made from existing metal, with no new mining. Lab-grown diamonds skip the mine. Smaller jewelers often work with recycled metal if you ask. Many sellers make claims here, so read them the way you would any eco label. A clear statement about the metal source is worth more than a vague one about values.
Skip the fast accessories
The biggest cut is in what you do not buy. Watch for:
- The checkout-line tote. A reusable bag you already own does the same job.
- Trend jewelry in big sets. One good pair of hoops outlasts ten pairs of plated ones.
- Plastic hair clips and headbands sold in packs. Buy one or two metal ones.
- Party favor jewelry for kids. It breaks before the car ride home. For a birthday, pick one small thing kids will use, as in planning a lower-carbon party.
When you want something, write it down and wait a week. The pause rule for family shopping covers how. Most of the time the want passes.
Care for the pieces you keep
- Take jewelry off before showers, swimming, and sleep. Soap, chlorine, and sweat wear plating and dull stones.
- Store pieces apart so they do not scratch each other. An egg carton or a sectioned box works.
- Keep silver in a closed bag or box. Air tarnishes it.
- Wipe leather bags with a damp cloth and condition them once or twice a year. Stuff them with paper when stored.
- Hang scarves or fold them flat. Wash wool ones by hand in cold water.
Teach kids the same habits
Kids love small shiny things, and party bags and checkout aisles are full of them. Give a child one real piece, such as a small silver chain or a wooden bead bracelet, and a box to keep it in. Let them see you fix a clasp instead of tossing a necklace. For gifts, ask relatives for one lasting piece rather than a handful of plastic ones. A child who owns one treasured bracelet learns more than one who owns twenty broken ones.
Pick one thing this week
Empty the jewelry drawer and fix one broken piece. Then make a rule: secondhand first for every accessory. The next time you want earrings or a bag, open a resale app or stop at a thrift shop before you open a new tab. One good secondhand piece, worn for years, has a lighter footprint than anything new.
Keep reading
Related guides
- Style
How to build a low-carbon capsule wardrobe for busy moms
A small wardrobe of clothes that all work together saves time in the morning and cuts the carbon from buying. Here is how to build one in a few weekends.
- Style
How to buy secondhand clothes for yourself and love them
Buying used clothes cuts the carbon from your wardrobe, but only if you wear them. Here is how to shop secondhand and come home with pieces you reach for.
- Style
How to choose a diaper bag or purse that lasts
A good bag can carry you from the baby years to the school years. Here is how to pick a diaper bag or purse that holds up, works hard, and lasts.