Cloth vs disposable diapers: which is lower carbon?
Cloth and disposable diapers have a similar carbon footprint on average. Here is how washing habits, reuse, and a hybrid setup lower the carbon of either one.
A baby goes through thousands of diapers. That makes diapers one of the first carbon questions new parents ask. The short answer is that neither type wins by default. How you use the diaper matters more than which kind you pick.
What the research says
A life cycle study from the UK Environment Agency, published in 2008, compared the climate impact of cloth and disposable diapers. It found the two were close. Cloth did not come out clearly ahead.
The reason is the washing. A cloth diaper needs hot water, detergent, and a dryer to get clean. That energy adds up. Disposables carry their carbon in the materials and the factory, and then in the landfill.
The same study found that cloth parents could cut their footprint with a few habits. Those habits are below. The study is old, and washers and grids have changed since, so treat it as a guide and not a final number.
Make cloth diapers lower carbon
Cloth gets better when you change how you wash and dry.
Wash full loads. A half-empty washer uses nearly the same energy as a full one. Store dirty diapers in a dry pail or wet bag until you have a full load. Wash every two to three days, since longer storage can leave stains and smells.
Use the lowest temperature that works. Follow the diaper maker’s care label first. Many modern diapers clean up in warm water with the right detergent. Our guide to cutting the carbon from family laundry covers detergent choice and load size.
Dry on a line or rack. The dryer is the biggest energy user in the cloth routine. Sun and open air also help lift stains. A rack by a window works in winter.
Reuse them. Cloth diapers last through more than one child. Using them for a second baby spreads the carbon of making them across twice as many diaper changes. Sell or give them away when you are done, and the same logic applies to the next family.
Buy secondhand. Many parents sell gently used cloth diapers online or through local parent groups. Wash them well before use. Skip any with torn elastic or worn waterproof lining.
Heat less water. Rinse in the washer, not in the sink with hot water. Our guide to cutting hot water use lists more ways to lower the tank temperature and use less of it.
Diaper laundry is one part of the household water bill. Using less water with four kids in the house covers the rest.
Make disposables lower carbon
Disposables are the right choice for many families. Not every home has a washer, time, or a daycare that accepts cloth. You can still cut carbon.
Buy the right size. A diaper that is too big leaks, and a leak means a wasted diaper and an extra outfit to wash. Move up a size only when the fit says so.
Change when needed. Check the diaper by touch. Many diapers hold more than parents expect. Do not stretch it past comfort, though. Long wet stretches can cause diaper rash. Ask your pediatrician if you are unsure.
Skip the wipe habit. A damp washcloth cleans a baby as well as a packaged wipe. Keep a stack by the changing table and toss them in the diaper pail liner or wet bag. They join the next load of laundry. Never flush wipes, even if the package says flushable. They can clog pipes.
Be careful with “compostable” claims. Most diapers end up in a landfill whatever the label says. A compostable diaper needs a commercial composting program that accepts diapers. Few areas offer one. Check with your local waste provider before you pay extra for the label.
Try a hybrid system
Many families mix the two. They use cloth at home and disposables at night, at daycare, or on trips. This cuts the total number of disposables without adding a laundry mountain.
Another hybrid option uses a washable cover with a disposable insert. Some inserts can be tossed in the trash. Others can be flushed or composted. Rules differ by town, so read the package and check with your local sewer or waste office first.
A diaper service is a third path. A service picks up dirty diapers and delivers clean ones. It is not available everywhere. If one operates near you, ask how they wash and dry, and how far the truck travels. A shared industrial wash can use less water and energy per diaper than a home washer. Ask the service for its numbers.
Check the practical limits first
Carbon is one factor. These matter too.
Ask your daycare if it accepts cloth. Some do, and some do not. A daycare that says no may still allow a hybrid with disposables during the day.
Count your laundry capacity. If you rent and share a laundry room, cloth takes more time and quarters. If you have a washer and a clothesline, cloth gets easier.
Think about your baby’s skin. Some babies get rashes in cloth, and some get them in disposables. Switch if a rash lasts, and talk to your pediatrician.
Diapers are one of many newborn decisions. Choosing lower-carbon baby gear for a newborn sorts the must-haves from the extras.
A simple way to decide
Start with what you have. If you own a washer and a place to dry clothes, buy a small set of cloth diapers secondhand and try them for a month. If the routine fits, keep going. If not, sell them and use disposables with the habits above.
Babies also outgrow diapers fast. When the time comes, potty training with less waste keeps the savings going, and cloth covers can stay on as backup at night.
Feeding is the other daily routine with a footprint. Feeding a baby with less waste and carbon covers bottles, jars, and pouches.
Keep reading
Related guides
- Kids
How to choose lower-carbon baby gear for a newborn
A newborn needs less gear than the registry lists suggest. Here is how to sort the must-haves from the extras, and how to get most of it used.
- Kids
How to potty train with less waste
Potty training can fill the trash with pull-ups, wipes, and plastic gear. Here is how to get through it with less waste and less stress.
- Food
How to feed a baby with less waste and carbon
Feeding a baby brings pouches, jars, bottles, and a lot of half-eaten food. Here is how to lower the waste and carbon while keeping your baby safe and fed.